Grand Theft Auto VI did something no Rockstar Games title had done before by shipping the game with a setting that mutes licensed music to help streamers avoid copyright claims. Credit where it is due. The previous Grand Theft Auto games didn't have this. The trouble is that muting is not the same as fixing. Turn it on and the game's licensed songs go quiet. Even then though, a few tracks may slip through and get you in trouble.

For what's arguably the most creator-driven launch in video game history, that is a strange corner to cut.

Grand Theft Auto V and Red Dead Redemption 2 shipped with nothing like this, so creators spent years muting the radio by hand, dropping the music slider or routing their own playlists in to stay claim-free. GTA 6 is the first Rockstar game to build the option in, sitting in Settings under Audio. It's a long overdue and welcome feature. Unfortunately, muting does not swap in a replacement, so the moment a licensed song would play, your stream or recording drops into dead silence, making scored cutscenes feel hollow. Worse, the setting does not catch everything.

Creators including Zack Scott and Casas Plays have reported that menu music and additional-score work, like Overmono's "Welcome to Leonida," still trigger Warner Music Group and Atlantic Records claims on YouTube even with the toggle on. Rockstar has not addressed the issue, so for now the fix is incomplete and leaves content creators with an overall lesser experience because it quiets too much and still misses the point of having the said feature anyway.

The frustrating part is that the better version already exists in smaller games. LEGO Batman: Legacy of the Dark Knight added a Streamer Mode this year that swaps licensed tracks for cleared, royalty-free ones, so the game still sounds like a game. Cyberpunk 2077 also did the same years earlier, replacing a handful of copyrighted songs rather than leaving a hole.

Both games keep the music playing where they replace tracks. Rockstar, on the biggest launch the medium has ever seen, shipped a less comprehensive option.

LEGO Batman and Cyberpunk 2077 already substitute royalty-free music instead.

The irony is sharp for anyone who followed the music story. We wrote about how GTA 6 set out to solve the problem of games losing their licensed music over time, a thoughtful bit of future-proofing for players. The creator-facing side got the opposite treatment. Streamers and content creators are a huge part of why this game is about to win a bunch of awards. Rockstar even quietly courted them for months before launch. Handing that same crowd a half-complete silencing feature feels like forgetting who helped carry the thing.

None of this is new territory for us. We track the full soundtrack live, we covered the 34-track album and we followed how Rockstar built the audio of Leonida from the radio up.

Give Rockstar the credit for shipping the toggle at all, it is more than the last two games offered, but for a studio this size, on a launch this loud, surely they can do better than a mute switch that leaves silence and still lets claims through.

The LEGO Batman and Cyberpunk 2077 fix is right there. GTA 6 is big enough to afford it.