The geography of Honolulu is pretty much already a GTA map. It's an island with a city on the southern shore. Done? Done. In all seriousness, basically all of Hawaii would make for an amazing GTA map. Add multiple islands, but pack them closer thanks to Rockstar's geographical liberty, connect them with bridges (or don't) and voila. Make them big enough to justify the use of land vehicles, while the use of sea and air vehicles will be made necessary due to, you know, being an archipelago. There are mountains, volcanos, cities and jungles, so the terrain would be diverse enough.
Crime
As shiny as things are in the geography department, this is where Honolulu's star falls. Honolulu is ranked as the 2nd safest city in the USA, with violent crimes being extremely rare. Drug use is high, however the violence that usually comes with it isn't as prevalent. Sure, seeing as it is a big city, you get some of the bad stuff, but nowhere near the levels we've seen in other cities evaluated in this series.
However there may be a "saving grace" — the legendary TV series, Hawaii Five-O has made linking the concepts of "crime" and "Hawaii" much easier for consumers, thus setting you loose in a pseudo-Honolulu with your typical assortment of GTA activities would seem less unreal.
Either way, there is plenty of theft and property crimes to go around, so stealing cars won't seem out of place at the slightest. Murder rampages and full-blown shoot-outs between gangs will be more of a stretch though.
Recognition
Honolulu will do better in this department than some of the more recent cities we've looked at. Granted, it may not be the city itself which is more recognisable, but the surroundings and whatever the GTA stand-in for Pearl Harbour would be.
Speaking of, Pearl Harbour. You'd be hard pressed to be any more recognisable than that. There's also the USS Arizona memorial, the ʻIolani Palace, the Aloha Tower and the Ala Moana Center. The region may be more recognisable for foreigners due to the popularity of the previously mentioned crime show, Hawaii Five-O — parts of which could totally be inspiration for the story.
Story Potential
As a member of a local gang, you are used to the regular small-time street crime that you've been doing for years. You've always had rivals, but conflicts never escalated beyond broken bones and a few slashes — in fact, the most dangerous thing you've ever come face-to-face with was a crowbar. However when one night your crew is attacked by a rival gang toting military-grade hardware and you are the sole survivor, you realise that crime in Paradise City has changed forever.
Find the people who are in charge of the illegal gun smuggling activity, discover the identities of the military contacts the rival gang has and exact revenge. Take control of your own gang, steal or buy them arms and ammo and eliminate the hostile gangs who now engage in open combat. Uncover the conspiracy aiming to have the gangs weaken one another, so the rivals with corrupt military officials backing them can step in and take control of the drug trade.
Final Verdict:
A+++
Pros: Absolutely perfect geography, Story Potential, Recognition, Easily solved issue of low crime rate
Cons: Low crime rate (but that's easily solved)
Yes, the crime rate is low. Yes, we docked points for that in previous articles. However, that particular issue is bridges much easier in the case of Honolulu than in that of other cities, and everything else is too perfect for us not to score this city the highest in the series so far.
Which city would you like us to evaluate next week?